WATERTOWN, N.Y. — The latest property transactions in the city of Watertown filed at the Jefferson County clerk’s office in July 2023:
Looking to buy or sell property in Jefferson County?
138 Wyoming Avenue
Seller: Alan W. Wright Estate, George H. Wright, Harpursville, NY
Buyer: Pasquale T. Surace, 17850 Sandy Creek Valley Rd., Watertown
Property: built in 1972, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in March 2000 for $67,000
City’s Total Assessment: $109,800
Price: $156,000 Filed: July 31
133 Scio Street
Seller: Brownstone Lodge, LLC, 12166 NYS Route 12, Chaumont
Buyer: Travis C. Bennett, 21468 CR 59, Chaumont
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 20023
City’s Total Assessment: $64,900
Price: $110,000 Filed: July 28
1636 State Street
Seller: Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp., 6555 Excellence Way, Plano, TX
Buyer: Mike Hall,
Property: built in 1930, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2022 for $40,759
City’s Total Assessment: $52,700
Price: $22,000 Filed: July 28
911 Salina Street
Seller: Myron C. Kehoe, Jr., 1115 Gotham St., Watertown
Buyer: Marty G. and Deborah Mathieu, 908 Salina St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $62,100
Price: $72,000 Filed: July 27
924 Summer Street
Seller: Kalon Jeter, Watertown, and Cinthia Jeter, 1709 Canyon Terrace Lane, Folsom, CA
Buyer: David Juarez Salas, 2-10 AHB 20358 Bagram Rd., Room 113B, Fort Drum
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in April 2022 for $112,194
City’s Total Assessment: $93,100
Price: $157,000 Filed: July 27
679 LeRay Street
Seller: Charles H. and Elizabeth B. Holland, 16534 Star School House Rd., Dexter
Buyer: Kristopher and Robert Bailey, 816 Brady Rd., Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1890, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in July 2008 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $91,500
Price: $190,700 Filed: July 26
522 Weldon Drive, C1
Seller: Thomas P. and Ellen C. O’Connor, 522 Weldon Dr., C1, Watertown
Buyer: Thomas P. and Ellen C. O’Connor, and O’Connor Family Trust
Property: built in 1986, 2 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2015 for $173,000
City’s Total Assessment: $172,000
Price: $0 Filed: July 26
622 Emerson Street
Seller: Xiaowei Chen, 137-40 45h Ave., Apt. 4J, Flushing, NY
Buyer: Michael Vasquez, 622 Emerson St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 2021 for $122,000
City’s Total Assessment: $99,200
Price: $169,000 Filed: July 26
Prepared by:
1371 Sunset Ridge
Seller: Judy A. Carpenter, 1371 Sunset Ridge, Watertown
Buyer: Zachery A. and Kathryn A. Chambers, 22209 Patricia Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1957, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2009 for $165,000
City’s Total Assessment: $160,300
Price: $309,900 Filed: July 26
352 S. Indiana Avenue
Seller: Phillip Venello, 2522 NYS Route 3, Mannsville
Buyer: Dakota J. Bingen, 50 Woodfield Place, Enterprise, AL
Property: built in 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2022 for $71,600
City’s Total Assessment: $93,100
Price: $200,000 Filed: July 26
823 Rutland Place
Seller: Rimpaw Properties, LLC, PO Box 315, Watertown
Buyer: Watertown Holdings, LLC, 7680 Goddard St., Colorado Springs, CO
Property: built in 1922, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2022 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $38,900
Price: $45,000 Filed: July 26
714 S. Massey Street
Seller: Cheryl L. Nielsen and Jeffrey Taylor, 714 S. Massey St., Watertown
Buyer: Nathan A. Barbieri, 1209 Farmington Dr., Apt. 6, Watertown
Property: built in 1917, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in March 2021 for $161,000
City’s Total Assessment: $130,900
Price: $200,000 Filed: July 25
100 Superior Street and Town of Brownville property
Seller: Legacy Home Stays, LLC, Wooster, Ohio
Buyer: Brandon K. Mandarino and Bridget A. Mandarino, Creekwood Dr., Watertown
Price: $236,000 Filed: July 25
1241 Harris Drive
Seller: Andre Chaput, 1241 Harris Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Marisa Marcellus, 1241 Harris Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1959, 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in June 2003 for $189,500
City’s Total Assessment: $216,900
Price: $225,000 Filed: July 24
329 & 333 W. Woodruff Street
Seller: Mark A. Smith and Susan J. Tague- Smith, 333 W. Woodruff St., Watertown
Buyer: Omar Salazar Tello and Amanda Salazar Tello, 232 Haley St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2015 for $170,000
City’s Total Assessment: $119,500
Price: $249,000 Filed: July 24
561 and 11 Eastern Boulevard
Seller: Gregory S. Matuszczak, 561 Eastern Blvd., Watertown
Buyer: James L. and Margaret Meier, 25991 Tawney Ct., Evans Mills
Property: built in 1927, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2010 for $80,300
City’s Total Assessment: $71,900
Price: $164,000 Filed: July 24
10 Seymour Street
Seller: City of Watertown
Buyer: Patricia Fay, 247 Seymour St., Watertown
Property: vacant land, sold in Aug. 2019 for $37,500
City’s Total Assessment: $6,100
Price: $254.30 Filed: July 24
126 Winslow Street
Seller: City of Watertown
Buyer: Georgena D’Aregenio, 923 Ives St., Watertown
Property: built in 1850, sold in Aug. 2019 for $37,500
City’s Total Assessment: $112,000
Price: $1,926 Filed: July 24
1200 Washington Street
Seller: Ann Marie Marra Fiorentino, 401 Stone St., Watertown
Buyer: Anthony J. Fiorentino, Anthony J. Fiorentino II and Fiorentino Legacy Trust
Property: built in 1959, commercial building, sold in Aug. 2008 for $38,000
City’s Total Assessment: $57,600
Price: $0 Filed: July 20
401 Stone Street
Seller: Ann Marie Marra Fiorentino, 401 Stone St., Watertown
Buyer: Anthony J. Fiorentino, Anthony J. Fiorentino II and Fiorentino Legacy Trust
Property: built in 1900, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $79,800
Price: $0 Filed: July 20
252 Moulton Street
Seller: Cyra Henderson-Bouie, 4319 Clymer Ct., Charlotte, NC
Buyer: Greater Future Development, 200 Washington St., Suite 203, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2022 for $34,000
City’s Total Assessment: $47,900
Price: $0 Filed: July 20
1205 Sherman Street
Seller: Kristofer Winsjansen, 1205 Sherman St., Watertown
Buyer: Alberto Pena Morales and Krystal Marie Tamayo Cruz, Fort Gordon, GA
Property: built in 1968, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in May 2019 for $131,600
City’s Total Assessment: $135,100
Price: $180,000 Filed: July 19
719 Franklin Street
Seller: Stephen A. Owens and Kostantina Owens, 719 Franklin St., Watertown
Buyer: Thomas A. Hiserdot, 6348 Decker Road, Bushkill, PA
Property: built in 1947, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold on Dec. 2022 for $120,000
City’s Total Assessment: $118,200
Price: $165,000 Filed: July 19
124 E. Division Street
Seller: Theresa M. and Patrick Marzano, 124 E. Division St., Apt. 2, Watertown
Buyer: Theresa M. Marzano, 124 E. Division St., Apt. 2, Watertown
Property: built in 1947, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold on Dec. 2022 for $120,000
City’s Total Assessment: $96,600
Price: $0 Filed: July 19
158 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Albert C. Barnes, Jr., by referee, Lisa Weldon, Esq.
Buyer: Joseph D. Murtha II, 100 St. Lawrence Ave., Brownville
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold on Nov. 2014 for $170,000
City’s Total Assessment: $142,400
Price: $75,000 Filed: July 17
717 Nellis Street
Seller: Jonathan and Nicole Grinsell, 717 Nellis St., Watertown
Buyer: Henri-Alexandre Noel III, 3201 1st Ave., Columbus, GA
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold on July 2022 for $200,000
City’s Total Assessment: $142,400
Price: $215,000 Filed: July 17
611 Cooper Street
Seller: Ezra W. Willis, Springfield, Missouri
Buyer: Aslan Gigolaev, Parker, Colorado
Property: built in 1870, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold on Oct. 2020 for $84,000
City’s Total Assessment: $75,800
Price: $125,000 Filed: July 17
721 Superior Street and Rear
Seller: Anthony and Michelle Matthews, 25 South St., Apt. D88, Marcellus
Buyer: Anthony and Angela Matthews
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold on April 2002 for $50,750
City’s Total Assessment: $55,850
Price: $0 Filed: July 17
151 Duffy Street
Seller: Megan L. Pistolese, 28913 SR 126, Black River
Buyer: Wendy S. Coen, 421 Riverside Dr., Apt. 3F, Clayton
Property: built in 1990, 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, purchased in Aug. 2010 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $30,000
Price: $97,950 Filed: July 17
901 Rail Drive
Seller: MLR Realty, LLC, 901 Rail Dr., Watertown
Buyer: US Foods, Inc., 9399 W. Higgins Road, Suite, 100, Rosemont, IL
Property: built in 2005, commercial building, purchased in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $4,588,200
Price: $7,014,000 Filed: July 14
315 S. Bellew Avenue, 935 Rail Drive
Seller: MLR Realty, LLC, 901 Rail Dr., Watertown
Buyer: US Foods, Inc., 9399 W. Higgins Road, Suite, 100, Rosemont, IL
Property: vacant land, purchased in Aug. 2022 for $0 from city of Watertown
City’s Total Assessment: $34,000
Price: $0 Filed: July 14
810 Rail Drive
Seller: MLR Realty, LLC, 901 Rail Dr., Watertown
Buyer: US Foods, Inc., 9399 W. Higgins Road, Suite, 100, Rosemont, IL
Property: vacant land, purchased in July 2022 for $100 from city of Watertown
City’s Total Assessment: $177,000
Price: $0 Filed: July 14
506 Arsenal Street
Seller: Ferris Holdings, LLC, 142 Arcade St., Suite 101, Watertown
Buyer: Cain Hall, LLC, PO Box 131, Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2020 for $97,881
City’s Total Assessment: $69,800
Price: $145,000 Filed: July 14
109 N. Meadow Street
Seller: Ferris Holdings, LLC, 142 Arcade St., Suite 101, Watertown
Buyer: Cain Hall, LLC, PO Box 131, Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2020 for $99,963
City’s Total Assessment: $79,700
Price: $155,000 Filed: July 14
117-119 N. Pleasant Street
Seller: Christopher M. and Arthur L. Desormo, 21400 SR 232, Watertown
Buyer: Cody L. Desormo, 502 Dimmick St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $67,600
Price: $75,000 Filed: July 14
215 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Revitalized Properties, LLC, 228 Ten Eyck St., Watertown
Buyer: Mathieu J. Julia D. Lavigne, 1215 Ohio St., Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2022 for $65,000
City’s Total Assessment: $93,300
Price: $220,000 Filed: July 13
202 Cedar Street; 305 N. Morgia Drive
Seller: Katherine C. Morgia, 202 Cedar St., Watertown
Buyer: Katherine C. Morgia Revocable Living Trust, Watertown
Property: built in 1965, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $167,200
Price: $0 Filed: July 13
420 Gaffney Drive
Seller: Jefferson Hostels, Inc., 380 Gaffney Dr., Watertown; Jefferson Community Mental Retardation Services, Company, Inc., 380 Gaffney Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Jefferson Hostels, Inc., 380 Gaffney Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1968, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $3,088,900
Price: $0 Filed: July 11
720 Cooper Street
Seller: Nelson C. Schorr, Sr., and Donna Schorr, 24679 Hinds Rd., Watertown
Buyer: Howard and Cormac Mahoney, North Hampton, NY
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Feb. 1998 for $32,000
City’s Total Assessment: $64,100
Price: $70,000 Filed: July 11
110 Girard Avenue
Seller: Timothy H. Lamay, Jr., 110 Girard Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Zachary Love and Janet Love, 110 Girard Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1940, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in June 2021 for $132,000
City’s Total Assessment: $109,000
Price: $157,000 Filed: July 11
442 Dimmick Street
Seller: Joseph M. Coniglio, 415 Harris Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Joey A. Johnson, Jr., and Molly K. Johnson, 536 Bradley St., Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in March 2004 for $61,000
City’s Total Assessment: $105,100
Price: $210,000 Filed: July 10
172 Dorsey Street
Seller: Adam P. Soules, 13733 Greene St., Adams Center
Buyer: John K. Stoop, 172 Dorsey St., Watertown
Property: built in 1962, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2009 for $10,000
City’s Total Assessment: $58,200
Price: $127,600 Filed: July 10
228 Colorado Avenue
Seller: Judith A. Rutledge, 228 Colorado Ave., Watertown, Leo W. Rutledge Estate
Buyer: Mark A. Rutledge, Wade A. Rutledge, Tracy M. Gebo, Trevor A. Rutledge
Property: built in 1927, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 1998 for $65,000
City’s Total Assessment: $83,500
Price: $0 Filed: July 10
136, 138 Central Street
Seller: NCPS Realty Group, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., PO Box 454, Watertown
Buyer: Christian D. Reese, 327 S. Hamilton St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2022 for $95,000
City’s Total Assessment: $144,800
Price: $265,000 Filed: July 10
675 S. Hamilton Street
Seller: Susan A. Gidley, Stamford, CT
Buyer: River Homes and Consulting, LLC, 211 Colorado Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1953, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $80,200
Price: $76,000 Filed: July 7
228 W. Lynde Street
Seller: Dorothy I. Fitzpatrick, 228 W. Lynde St., Watertown
Buyer: Dorothy I. Fitzpatrick Life Estate; Brent I. Fitzpatrick
Property: built in 1870, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in July 2000 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $59,800
Price: $0 Filed: July 7
1362 Sherman Street
Seller: Clarissa A. Godfrey, 1362 Sherman St., Watertown
Buyer: Carol A. Hughes, 16091 CR 156, Watertown
Property: built in 1944, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in July 2021 for $157,000
City’s Total Assessment: $123,100
Price: $173,000 Filed: July 7
333 and 329 W. Woodruff Street
Seller: Alexandra C. Smith, 2202 Palo Alto St., Navarre, FL
Buyer: Mark A. Smith and Susan J. Tague-Smith, 333 W. Woodruff St., Watertown
Property: built in 1985, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2020 for $273,000
City’s Total Assessment: $260,400
Price: $0 Filed: July 6
333 and 329 W. Woodruff Street
Seller: Margaret S. Ramsay, Merseyside, UK, and Alexandra C. Smith, Navarre, FL
Buyer: Alexandra C. Smith, 2202 Palo Alto St., Navarre, FL
Property: built in 1985, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2020 for $273,000
City’s Total Assessment: $260,400
Price: $0 Filed: July 6
430 Lachenauer Drive
Seller: Jorden D. Pope and Melissa S. Pope, 430 Lachenauer Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Joel F. Markham and Jill A. Markham, Niskayuna, NY
Property: built in 1985, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2020 for $273,000
City’s Total Assessment: $260,400
Price: $360,000 Filed: July 6
227 Thompson Boulevard
Seller: Nicholas S. Penna, 5981 Thomas Road, Fort Belvoir, VA
Buyer: Christopher and Kelsea Dopler, 1317 Windrow Dr., Hinesville, GA
Property: built in 1945, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2012 for $239,000
City’s Total Assessment: $209,000
Price: $250,000 Filed: July 5
450 Harris Drive
Seller: Jacob A. and Milena Mazurek, 450 Harris Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Jordan S. Smith and Nikki L. Smith, 701 Mill St., Mannsville
Property: built in 1959, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 2021 for $308,000
City’s Total Assessment: $260,000
Price: $363,000 Filed: July 3
Prepared by:
811 Academy Street
Seller: Donna M. Combs, Jacksonville, FL
Buyer: Benjamin J. Burt and Shannon M. Burt, 256 Michigan Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in June 2022 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $90,100
Price: $116,600 Filed: July 3
702 LeRay Street
Seller: Greater Future Development, 702 LeRay St., Watertown
Buyer: Alicia Hollenbeck, 2723 Cumberland Dr., Texas City, TX
Property: built in 1880, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2021 for $95,000
City’s Total Assessment: $69,600
Price: $0 Filed: July 3